We have been approached by a client, who has a business insurance policy which falls due for renewal at the end of May next year, 2012. They are going to be moving to a new premises and increasing their stock sum insured within the next week or so. Their existing insurance broker has quoted them an additional premium, which was expected due to the changes. However, the premium they are being charged, from September to May is nearly £2,000. On top of their existing, the full years premium is going to hit the £5,000 mark.
When they spoke to us they mentioned that their existing broker had advised that the cancellation rights where that they could request the full years commission. This caused a bit of a problem, we quoted them a full annual premium, for the new premises, of £3,800. Overall then a saving of over 20%. They are quite within their rights to cancel their insurance cover as there has been a material change in the risk ie the move of premises and the increased sum insured.
Their existing business broker tried to get them to stump up their full years commission. On £5,000 they were earning an unbelievable 30%, which meant that they were going to try and bill the client for their “lost” commission from now til the normal expiry. The slight difficulty is that any broker or service provider can put in some quite onerous terms. You would not normally expect something like this to happen, in that the broker thought they could stick in a bill for £700 plus.
We however checked which policy they were cancelling and it was with an insurer that gives a full pro-rata refund, unless a claim had been submitted. Also, thre brokers terms of business (which we must all legally provide) was very woolly when it mentioned “full commission”. We suggested some text for the client to provide to the broker to force them not to try and over-charge. Thankfully, the broker realised that they were pushing it a bit.
What does this mean for the average business then? If you have a business package or commercial combined insurance, then thankfully not too much because this sort of thing does not happen too often. If you are faced with a similar situation though, please don’t think that you have to go with what the broker says. You can usually argue the toss with most of them and if you are strong enough in your complaint, you should usually win through. Any problems, please call Businessinsure and ask to speak to Paul Roach.

