If you are looking for a cheap business insurance quote, then the more choice you can get, or have, then the better things will be. Or, so you would think. We recently quoted for a customers pub insurance, we went to six insurers and got a range of quotes from £760 to £4,000. The customer took out the lower quote as we recommended this one, as it included legal expenses and equipment breakdown cover.
But, with the £4,000 quote, we were surprised to find out that this company had also quoted the client, through another broker at just under £1,000. The quotes we obtain were from a web quote system and if the information declared was the same, then the quote should be the same.
However, we raised this with the insurers only to be told that the broker who quoted the alternative had a “special deal” arrangement, allowing them to quote at substantial discounts. Now, I am happy to accept that a big business insurance broker that puts most of it’s business with Insurer A will get better prices. These you would expect to be in the 5-10% difference mark. 75% less is just a bit too much.
Complain as we did, the insurers basically were not that concerned. The good news is that we got the business anyway, but the moot point is that, if you think you are getting choice, then maybe it is not what you think. The best way to get proper choice, is to go to two or three different brokers, as opposed to two or three insurers direct.

